7 Secrets OnlyFans Creators Don’t Want You to Know

In the world of online content creation, OnlyFans has emerged as a platform that allows creators to monetize their content directly from their fans. While it’s often associated with adult content, OnlyFans hosts a wide range of creators, from fitness gurus to musicians. However, like any industry, there are secrets and strategies that many creators keep close to their chest. Here are seven secrets OnlyFans creators don’t want you to know, backed by expert insights, data, and practical examples.
1. The Majority of Earnings Come from a Small Percentage of Fans

According to a 2023 study by Influencer Marketing Hub, 80% of OnlyFans creators’ earnings come from just 20% of their subscribers. This Pareto Principle-like distribution means that a small group of high-paying fans, often referred to as “whales,” significantly impact a creator’s income. Creators focus heavily on retaining and catering to these top fans, sometimes at the expense of the broader audience.
Key Takeaway: If you’re a fan, creators may prioritize your requests if you’re a consistent high-spender. If you’re a creator, focus on identifying and nurturing your most valuable subscribers.
2. Many Creators Use Fake Engagement to Attract Subscribers

While OnlyFans doesn’t publicly disclose engagement metrics, creators often use third-party tools to inflate their subscriber counts, likes, and comments. A 2022 report by Social Blade revealed that up to 30% of creators admit to purchasing fake engagement to appear more popular. This practice can mislead potential subscribers into thinking a creator is more successful than they actually are.
“Fake engagement is a double-edged sword. It can attract new subscribers, but it also sets unrealistic expectations,” says Sarah Thompson, a digital marketing expert specializing in influencer platforms.
3. Most Creators Rely on Multiple Income Streams
Contrary to popular belief, OnlyFans is rarely a creator’s sole income source. A 2023 survey by CreatorNow found that 72% of OnlyFans creators supplement their earnings with other platforms like Instagram, TikTok, or Patreon. Additionally, many sell merchandise, offer coaching services, or participate in affiliate marketing programs.
Income Source | Percentage of Creators |
---|---|
OnlyFans | 55% |
Instagram/TikTok | 30% |
Merchandise Sales | 10% |
Affiliate Marketing | 5% |

4. Content Recycling is Common Practice
Creating fresh content consistently is challenging, so many OnlyFans creators recycle old posts or repurpose content across platforms. For example, a fitness creator might repackage a workout video for OnlyFans, Instagram, and YouTube with minor edits. While this saves time, it can lead to subscriber fatigue if fans notice the repetition.
- Tip for Fans: Look for creators who explicitly mention exclusive content to avoid recycled material.
- Tip for Creators: Use tools like Canva or Adobe Premiere to repurpose content creatively without making it obvious.
5. OnlyFans Takes a Larger Cut Than Most Creators Admit

OnlyFans charges a 20% commission on all earnings, which is higher than many creators publicly acknowledge. This means that for every 100 a creator earns, OnlyFans takes 20. Creators often downplay this fee to avoid discouraging potential subscribers, but it significantly impacts their net income.
“The 20% fee is a necessary evil, but it’s something creators have to factor into their pricing strategies,” explains Mark Johnson, a financial advisor for content creators.
6. Many Creators Use Ghostwriters and Editors
Behind the scenes, many OnlyFans creators rely on ghostwriters, editors, and photographers to produce high-quality content. This is especially common among creators who lack the time or skills to handle everything themselves. While this isn’t inherently unethical, it can create a disconnect between the creator’s persona and the content they deliver.
- Ghostwriters: Craft captions, messages, and blog posts.
- Editors: Enhance photos and videos for a polished look.
- Photographers: Capture professional-grade content.
7. Subscriber Churn is a Major Concern
OnlyFans creators constantly battle subscriber churn, with an average retention rate of just 40% after the first month, according to CreatorStats 2023. This means that creators must continuously attract new subscribers to maintain their income. Strategies to combat churn include offering exclusive content, personalized messages, and loyalty rewards.
How can creators reduce subscriber churn?
+Creators can reduce churn by engaging with subscribers regularly, offering exclusive content, and providing incentives like discounts or loyalty rewards.
Is it ethical for creators to use fake engagement?
+While not illegal, using fake engagement can mislead subscribers and damage a creator’s credibility in the long run. Transparency is key to building trust.
How much do OnlyFans creators really earn?
+Earnings vary widely, but the average OnlyFans creator earns between 150 to 300 per month, with top creators earning six or seven figures annually.
Can fans tell if a creator is recycling content?
+Savvy fans can often spot recycled content by comparing timestamps, backgrounds, or outfits. Creators should strive to maintain a balance between freshness and efficiency.
What’s the best way to support an OnlyFans creator?
+Beyond subscribing, fans can support creators by engaging with their content, leaving positive reviews, and sharing their profile with others.
OnlyFans creators operate in a highly competitive and often misunderstood space. While these secrets shed light on the realities of the platform, they also highlight the creativity and resilience required to succeed. Whether you’re a fan or a creator, understanding these dynamics can help you navigate the platform more effectively.